I have never used NRO or The Corner to claim that the Catholic Church is the One True Church, but I don’t think you’ll ever hear B16 making a similar pronouncement on one HRC.
I suspect Goldberg is thinking–if only for a second–”Sista Lopez has a point.”
UPDATE: A rabbi just e-mailed in agreement. And another e-mailer who was in Flushing Meadow this weekend asked me for a priest recommendation.