John P, I think you’re too harsh on Andrew Sullivan. Yes, the line he has taken on his blog (a daily must-read even if I haven’t always agreed with what he was writing) has seemed occasionally inconsistent, but I’d much rather read the work of someone who’s thinking aloud (which is what he often has seemed to be doing) than that of someone who isn’t thinking.
On Islamofascism, his views appear fairly straightforward to me. He understands the danger, he thinks it should be fought, but he is highly critical, sometimes rightly, sometimes wrongly, of the way in which this war is being conducted. Fair enough, I reckon.