The Corner

Charlotte Simmons Unmasked

We have some very intelligent readers who come up with very interesting

ideas. Here’s one of the best from the last few days:

“Mr. Derbyshire—Based on your review and because I now have a daughter in

college I picked up and have just finished reading I Am Charlotte Simmons.

It occurred to me that there were some slight character parallels, perhaps

echoes, from The Hunchback of Notre Dame.

“According to my thinking they are as follows:

“Quasimodo (Pope of Fools) —- Jojo

“Archdeacon Claude Frollo — Buster Roth for one facet of his personality

(the adoptive father) , Prof. Quat for another(the twisted moralist) and

Prof. Starling for yet another ( the alchemist)

“Jehan Frollo — Hoyt Thorpe

“Esmerelda — Charlotte Simmons

“Pierre Gringoire — Adam Gellin

“Fleur-de-Lys de Gondelaurier — Beverly

“Phoebus de Chateaupers — Vance

“Perhaps you havent read Hunchback since prep school, but still I hope you

find this idea of some interest.

“Sincerely — [Name]“

I love this kind of thing. I reread Hunchback 6-7 yrs ago, when my kids

were little & the Disney version came out. I saw the Disney thing, thought:

“I don’t recall it being ANYTHING like that,” went & reread the book, & was

pleased to find it the same sinister riot of sadism, necrophilia, gratuitous

violence & soft porn that I remembered so fondly from my adolescence.

Should be sold in a brown paper bag.

John Derbyshire — Mr. Derbyshire is a former contributing editor of National Review.
Exit mobile version