It is right to know about individuals and not merely masses. Charlotte Higgins, the chief culture writer of the Guardian, has written about Volodymyr Vakulenko and his murder by Russian forces. Vakulenko was a writer. To read about him and his family, and what happened to them, is instructive. For this article, go here.
• In recent days, Russia has bombarded Odessa. This is a bulletin from the chief foreign-affairs correspondent of the Wall Street Journal:
Headquarters building of Ukraine’s main port, in Odesa, after this night’s Russian missile strike. Putin seeks to make future Ukrainian food exports impossible. Zero effect on the military campaign, of course. pic.twitter.com/EVpZBFWyMU
— Yaroslav Trofimov (@yarotrof) July 20, 2023
Russian forces struck the cathedral, too:
Odesa’s main Orthodox cathedral. Established in 1794, destroyed by Stalin in 1936, rebuilt under an independent Ukraine and destroyed again by Putin in 2023. One of several historical parts of central Odesa, a UNESCO world heritage site, hit by Russian missiles strikes today. pic.twitter.com/X9BvICUbQ4
— Yaroslav Trofimov (@yarotrof) July 22, 2023
I keep hearing that Vladimir Putin is a great defender of “Christian civilization.”
Did Ukrainians destroy their own city? Here, again, is Trofimov:
Russian propaganda, which told us that the Bucha massacre never happened and that Russia never shot down MH17, is now blaming the destruction of central Odesa on misfired Ukrainian air defenses. Of course it would.
— Yaroslav Trofimov (@yarotrof) July 23, 2023
Here is something to make one say, “Viva l’Italia”:
Italy will help Ukraine restore the Transfiguration Cathedral in Odesa and other cultural monuments destroyed by the Russians.
"Italy, which has unique restoration competence on a global scale, is ready to reconstruct the cathedral and other Ukrainian cultural values," PM… pic.twitter.com/eiz8syaKtH
— Iuliia Mendel (@IuliiaMendel) July 23, 2023
• An article in the Washington Post, on one aspect of the evil of Russia’s war: “Ukraine is now the most mined country. It will take decades to make safe.”
• What is it like to go to school in Ukraine? Here is a message from Tymofiy Mylovanov, the president of the Kyiv School of Economics (who earned his Ph.D. at the University of Wisconsin and who is even now an associate professor at the University of Pittsburgh):
Bomb shelters as classrooms. Candlelit nights for studying. Exams interrupted by air raid sirens. No student should endure this, yet Kyiv School of Economics's @kse_ua graduates have. Their resilience awes me. Let me tell you about Ukraine's class of 2023. 1/ pic.twitter.com/H8zowHSnme
— Tymofiy Mylovanov (@Mylovanov) July 22, 2023
• Here is a message from Senator J. D. Vance, Republican of Ohio:
🚨WATCH: @JDVance1 SLAMS Joe Biden for taking orders from the military industrial complex
“The profit motives of the defense contractors are motivating our posture in Ukraine…We’re not making enough to arm our own troops. We need to stop supporting the Ukraine war effort.” pic.twitter.com/2OmwUlRcjs
— Senator Vance Press Office (@SenVancePress) July 18, 2023
In an earlier era, some people on the left said that the United States was prosecuting the Vietnam War for the benefit of Dow Chemical. Now we hear similar claims from the other side: Biden is “taking orders from the military industrial complex”; “The profit motives of the defense contractors are motivating our posture in Ukraine.”
Note another line from Vance as well: “We need to stop supporting the Ukraine war effort.” By “the Ukraine war effort,” the senator means the struggle of people to fend off invaders who are murdering, raping, and deporting them en masse, and who are seeking to re-subjugate them.
Russia is the aggressor, not Ukraine. That elementary fact — like other such facts — needs regular emphasis.
Here is another Republican senator, Mike Lee of Utah:
Not our war. Pretending otherwise is dangerous. pic.twitter.com/hgA9sLKiZP
— Mike Lee (@BasedMikeLee) July 20, 2023
Senator Lee adds, “Brought to you by the Military Industrial Complex™.” (The trademark symbol is an interesting touch.)
In 2014, I wrote an essay that readers may find of interest: “Ike as Weapon: The use and abuse of Eisenhower’s Farewell Address, with its warning about the ‘military-industrial complex.’” Go here.
As you may have observed, Senator Lee tweets as “BasedMikeLee.” What does “based” mean? For an explanation from Dictionary.com, go here.
• Governor Ron DeSantis, running for president, said, “I wish the D.C. elites cared as much about our border as they do about the Ukraine–Russia border.” Is that really his understanding of the Ukraine war? Some border dispute? Or is he serving up “boob bait”?
• About the war, Secretary of State Antony Blinken said this: “The objective was to erase Ukraine from the map, to eliminate its independence, its sovereignty, to subsume it into Russia.” He added, “That failed a long time ago.” He went on to say, “Unlike the Russians, Ukrainians are fighting for their land, for their future, for their country, for their freedom.”
• Here is an interesting development: “UK’s MI6 boss says Putin under pressure, invites Russians to spy for Britain.” For that article, from Reuters, go here.
• An interesting statement from the president of Chile:
"Today it is Ukraine, but tomorrow it could be any one of us," Chilean President Gabriel Boric says at the EU-CELAC Summit. "What is happening in Ukraine is an unacceptable imperialist war of aggresion that violates international law." pic.twitter.com/czHLSqqe3o
— Benjamin Alvarez (@BenjAlvarez1) July 18, 2023
• Bret Stephens has penned a column called “What I Learned in Ukraine.” He writes,
NATO countries are paying for their long-term security in money, which is cheap, and munitions, which are replaceable. Ukrainians are counting their costs in lives and limbs lost.
Also,
. . . the Polish people remained, in Ronald Reagan’s apt words, “magnificently unreconciled to oppression.”
Today, it is Poland’s neighbors in Ukraine who are magnificently unreconciled to invasion.
• Evgeny Kissin is a Soviet-born pianist who is a citizen of both the United Kingdom and Israel. He is one of the most famous musicians in the world. He came to our attention in 1984, when he was twelve — playing the Chopin concertos in a red Young Pioneers scarf. He grew into a noble human being.
“In June 2021,” he writes, “I performed in Odessa, and my visit there became one of the greatest impressions in my life.” Daily, he sends money to Ukraine. He urges the saving of Odessa and the entire country. Some years ago, he funded the English translation of Vladimir Bukovsky’s book Judgment in Moscow. Not your average musician, Kissin, and not your average person.