Elections

Second Republican Primary Debate: Live Updates

From left: North Dakota governor Doug Burgum, former New Jersey governor Chris Christie, former South Carolina governor Nikki Haley, Florida governor Ron DeSantis, entrepreneur Vivek Ramaswamy, Senator Tim Scott (R., S.C.), and former vice president Mike Pence attend the second Republican presidential primary debate at the Ronald Reagan Presidential Library in Simi Valley, Calif., September 27, 2023. (Pedro Ugarte/AFP via Getty Images)
The 2024 Republican presidential candidates meet Wednesday night for their second debate, this time in Simi Valley, Calif., hosted by Fox Business Network. Front-runner Donald Trump, once more, is not attending. A total of seven candidates are: Ron DeSantis, Nikki Haley, Mike Pence, Tim Scott, Chris Christie, Vivek Ramaswamy, and Doug Burgum. Follow along for live updates and analysis from the NR team:
Michael Brendan Dougherty

I think Scott failed a bit in this debate. Saying that 90 percent of American aid to Ukraine is a “loan” that will be paid back by NATO is really not right. He’s trying to say that the vast bulk of money is spent in the American defense contracting industry. That’s true. But the money and materiel it produces is consumed.

Dan McLaughlin

In Florida, “the Democratic Party lies in ruins” – DeSantis barging into the Haley-Scott fight to brag on his throne of skulls.

Noah Rothman

Fox pitting Haley and Scott against each other, unprompted, feels like a signal to donors and party officials to focus on winnowing the field of native sons and daughters in the Palmetto State to one ahead of the New Year.

Kathryn Jean Lopez

It’s only the second primary debate, and so many of them sound exhausted. Does not bode well.

Mark Wright

Jeff writes: “Haley is now genuinely scrapping for keeps with DeSantis to be the non-Trump alternative.”

Yep — she’s taken on Trump, Vivek, Scott, and DeSantis directly tonight. No idea how it will play with the voters, but it’s clear that she’s determined to not be a wall flower in the final pre-Iowa months of this campaign.

Haley is acting like a pol who wants to be a front-runner.

Ramesh Ponnuru

DeSantis says he’ll be the first president since 1988 who has served in a war overseas. Every election since the Cold War that has pit a veteran against a non-veteran, the veteran has lost. But that’s a small sample size and perhaps a coincidence.

Dan McLaughlin

The Haley-DeSantis exchange did not go well for Haley.

Jim Geraghty

We’re an hour and forty minutes in, the candidates are tired and irritated with each other, they know their opportunities for having a big dramatic moment are dwindling, and right now you can see it in the faces of Haley and DeSantis. Ironically, so far, I feel like they’ve both had good arguments.

Jeffrey Blehar

Haley’s attack on DeSantis for banning fracking is weird, because nobody actually believes that PRESIDENT Ron DeSantis (as opposed to Governor DeSantis, having to deal with the Everglades and the FL coast as a political issue) would ban fracking.

The real takeaway: Haley is now genuinely scrapping for keeps with DeSantis to be the non-Trump alternative.

Kathryn Jean Lopez

Yes, Pence sounds like a throwback. But he also was vice president under Donald Trump.

NR Staff comprises members of the National Review editorial and operational teams.
Exit mobile version