Elections

Second Republican Primary Debate: Live Updates

From left: North Dakota governor Doug Burgum, former New Jersey governor Chris Christie, former South Carolina governor Nikki Haley, Florida governor Ron DeSantis, entrepreneur Vivek Ramaswamy, Senator Tim Scott (R., S.C.), and former vice president Mike Pence attend the second Republican presidential primary debate at the Ronald Reagan Presidential Library in Simi Valley, Calif., September 27, 2023. (Pedro Ugarte/AFP via Getty Images)
The 2024 Republican presidential candidates meet Wednesday night for their second debate, this time in Simi Valley, Calif., hosted by Fox Business Network. Front-runner Donald Trump, once more, is not attending. A total of seven candidates are: Ron DeSantis, Nikki Haley, Mike Pence, Tim Scott, Chris Christie, Vivek Ramaswamy, and Doug Burgum. Follow along for live updates and analysis from the NR team:
Rich Lowry

Burgum nails it on electric cars

Michael Brendan Dougherty

Tim Scott wisely takes his response time to rehearse his winning personal story, which is an undisguised hymn of patriotism.

Dominic Pino

Pence sticking with right-to-work, which Michigan Democrats took away from auto workers.

Jeffrey Blehar

The three-person moderator panel inevitably comes across like this debate is being broadcast simultaneously into English (Perino), Spanish (Calderón), and WASP (Varney).

Jim Geraghty

Man, is it just me or does Mike Pence look like he’s aged a decade in the past few years? Then again, I suppose he had some real unusual and unparalleled stress in his life in early 2021.

Michael Brendan Dougherty

Vivek, aware of the polls, shows sympathy for the United Auto Workers without endorsing union leaders. Then transitions to a message of condemning Bidenomics, and preaching a mostly conservative catechism on economic growth, deregulation, and energy abundance. Again, his high level of energy stands out- even if this crowd doesn’t love him.

Rich Lowry

Vivek‘s answer seemed great, but muted reaction

Ramesh Ponnuru

Scott’s opening answer is a nice example of how a candidate can move on after a mistake. His initial comparison of the UAW strike to the PATCO strike made no sense, so when asked about it he just alluded to the difference and made a better case.

Michael Brendan Dougherty

On the Commentary Magazine daily podcast, Matt Continetti suggested that every candidate answer every question by bringing the subject back to the chaos at the border, and the economy. I agree. And Tim Scott is up for that challenge.

Jeffrey Blehar

The weird tripartite pas-de-trois of the debate format’s opening question bodes ill. Tim Scott handled the question well, however, minus too much drama at the end there.

NR Staff comprises members of the National Review editorial and operational teams.
Exit mobile version